Text towards a model for the study of film adaptation as intersemiotic translation. The three disciplines of adaptation studies, semiotics, and translation studies share a common interest in the transference of texts across modes of signification such as textual, visual, oral, aural, gestural or kinesic. Exploring indexicality in intersemiotic translation. Intersemiotic translation literary and linguistic multimodality aba. A bilingual person is the one who knows both the languages involved in the conversation and is able to. Cognitive artefacts have a huge variety of forms and are manipulated in many different ways and domains. This article aims at providing a concise background of the translation studies, theories and areas, as well as a discussion on the current issues and future perspectives. The translation source is in the functional position of the sign, and works as a predictive model for artistic creation. The act of translating from one language to another involves a political, culturally embedded process that can impact both the originating and the receiving culture. In this paper i examine cases where spatial composition produces intersemiotic translations for artistic and advertising purposes in a period where globalization permits and profits by the intertextual evoking of cultural texts. Intersemiotic translation is viewed as the basis of cultural communication through which ideas are circulated, translated and explained using language, images and other semiotic resources. The intersemiotics translation or transposition deals with two or more completely different codes, e.
Asia pacific translation and intercultural studies. The journal of translation is an academic journal of translation theory and practice with a special interest in bible translation and in translation involving minority languages and cultures. The paper discusses how film adaptation becomes a mode of inter semiotic translation focussing on kaliyattom, an adaptation of othello, a shakespearean play. In his seminal paper, on linguistic aspects of translation jacobson 19592000. In this article we approach a case of intersemiotic. Intersemiotic translation and transformational creativity. Intersemiotic translation, adaptation, transposition. Translation and adaptation have much in common, as both processes involve a transposition of meaning and are highly contextdependent aragay 2005. Roman jakobson on linguistic aspects of translation full text. This special interest group proposes to chronicle and reflect on this process of collaborative translation, chart its impact in communities or other public.
Introduction semiotics of translation, translation in. We are immersed in this kind of translation whenever we use different words and phrases to communicate similar meanings. Intersemiotic translation, cognitive artefact, and. Author information roman jakobson was a famous russian linguist and literary theorist. Sokolovsky siberian federal university 82 svobodny, krasnoyarsk, 660041 russia 1 received 9. Journal of specialised translation issue 5 january 2006 42 intersemiotic translation.
Then, as it was meant for ballet, there was a ballet dancer who translated further, from the two previous codes into a dancing one, which. Abstractone way of transferring the culture and identity of a nation is through book illustrations as a kind of intersemiotic translation. Its purpose is to encourage scholarship, to enlighten the reader, to stimulate thought and discussion, and to promote appropriate crosscultural and crosslinguistic communication. This book explores the practical aspects of intersemiotic translation, examining how. The intralingual translation of a word uses either another, more or less synonymous, word or resorts to a circumlocution.
Article pdf available in semiotica 2015206 august 2015 with 8,783 reads. Intralingual translation shares with translation proper the idea of changing form but maintaining meaning and the need to adjust to different audiences and expectations. Daniella aguiar, pedro ata and joao queiroz in their article intersemiotic translation and transformational creativity approach a case of intersemiotic translation as a paradigmatic example of. Ohalloran, sabine tan peter wignell curtin university 1. Gorlee goes back to jakobsons three types of translation, focusing most deeply on the intersemiotic type. Intersemiotic translation and transformational creativity philarchive. From this perspective, intersemiotic translation is conceptualised through the principle of resemiotisation which is concerned with how semiotic choices are translated over time as. If youre interested in audiovisual translation, watch the invisible subtitler, a 23minute documentary by arc pictures, featuring subtitlers and leading scholars. Going back to jakobsons idea, this work also intends to show that intersemiotic translation is embedded in the other two types of translations suggested by this renowned linguist. Intersemiotic translation as an anticipatory artefact. Intersemiotic translation indian journal of comparative. Intralingual and intersemiotic translation we have seen that descriptions of translation claim that meaning can be carried across between languages, however dressed up or repackaged it is, and we have begun to question the assumption that meaning remains unchanged during this process.
It was published in on translation, a compendium of seventeen papers edited by reuben arther brower. This essay examines the use of visual paratexts such as book illustrations in literary translation. What was totally new to me were the problems connected with translating shakespeares plays into a sign language and the. Pdf spatial composition as intersemiotic translation. This article explores the use of indexicality for understanding the emergence of socialcultural habits. Omar khayyam is an iranian poet whose fame, thanks to fitzgerald, is now worldwide. It focuses specifically on the issue of intersemiotic translation, questioning and showing what it means to translate from one language to another, such as from the novel to. Literary and linguistic multimodality abacarina parlog this book explores the practical aspects of intersemiotic translation, examining how different signs and sign sets can be transposed into different kinds of semiotic forms of reference. International journal of social science and humanity, vol. This article discusses the creativity and originality that can be generated by both interlingual and intersemiotic translations.
This paper draws on jakobsons tripartite division of the notion of translation, and ecos discussion of the terms in his book on translation, mouse or rat. If the inline pdf is not rendering correctly, you can download the pdf file here. However, translation extends beyond linguistic translation and the. Intersemiotic translation, under whatever name and guise, since new terms are being suggested daily, has been gaining renewed momentum and it can be seen in a new light as a bridge concept between translation, adaptation, and by default semiotics. View intersemiotic translation research papers on academia. The first one is translation between languages, also known as interlingual translation or translation proper. This theoretical approach is discussed in detail in section 3. This means to say that translation processes dominated by iconicity play a fundamental role not only in traveling across different historical languages, but also as the very condition of such travels. Khayyams works have been translated to many languages and even some illustrators have tried to transform khayyams quatrains into illustrations. Intersemiotic translation provides an interactive, participative platform with the potential to engage individuals and communities in connecting with cultures different from their own. Therefore, even if we ignored all the above claims concerning the autonomy of colour as a semiotic system, the utilization of multimodality only would make intersemiotic translation possible as long as there is another semiotic system. Saying almost the same thing nicosie novembre 1012, nicosia, cyprus. The objections of a german lady, who criticized the new translation of shakespeare presented in a theater because she had her original german shakespeare on her bookshelf at home 160, are highly amusing.
In section 2, i will examine the issue of intersemiotic translation as applied to print. Meaning, the journal of philosopby, xliii 1946, 91. In 2002 a modern chinese dance was set to mahlers masterpiece by chiang ching, a. Project muse shakespeare and the language of translation. Consequently, such classification intralingual, interlingual, intersemiotic can be subject to questioning and further development.
The following article is focused on particularities of transferring culturally marked words in the subtitled translation from english into russian and romanian. Nov 10, 2019 intersemiotic translation translation of the verbal sign by a nonverbal sign, for example, music or image. Intersemiotic translation and cultural literacy my cms. Intersemiotic translation translation of the verbal sign by a nonverbal sign, for example, music or image. Intersemiotic translation research papers academia. A digital online journal for translators, interpreters, and interested friends of the translation industry.
Intersemiotic translation it can be described as a cognitive artefact designed as a predictive, generative, and metasemiotic tool that distributes artistic creativity. However, we should not overhastily consider intralingual translation as forming the fundament of the other two kinds of translation mentioned by jakobson, namely of interlingual translation and intersemiotic translation i. For mahler the idea of his text being a translation. These standards privilege the original, whose meaning, referent, and effect the translation is held to reproduce st. Thus globalization gives us the chance to promote new messages that contribute, in their turn, to a series of cultural interpretations that enrich the forms of modern. Interlingual translation now we are going to adopt a broad definition of translation offered by the russianamerican linguist roman jakobson and look at three types of translation. On jakobsons intersemiotic translations in asterix comics. In our case, it is the verbal system, as we will see below. It focuses specifically on the issue of intersemiotic translation, questioning and showing what it means to translate from one language to another, such as from the novel to the medium of film, and to what extent the term translation is used metaphorically or whether it is semantically extended to include a broader notion of. The concept of intersemiotic translation exposes a current and relevant area of discipline. To study the significance of the recent convictions in the application of multimodal tools in teaching vocabularies, the present study sets out to investigate the extent of vocabulary learning within two different environments. However, translation extends beyond linguistic translation and the interpretation of linguistic signs through rewordings to intersemiotic translation, which, in its original sense, was seen as involving the interpretation of linguistic signs by means. The question of how much the quality of translation influences the intersemiotic translation, which adaptation is believed to be, will be examined in. However, while one translation was appreciated by many, including the author of the original, the other one did not get much credit and features many inaccuracies, which will be presented below.
Roman jakobson 18961982 on linguistic aspects of translation 1959 keywords. We revisit some of the translation types in week 4 on translation quality. Lems the futurological congress and solaris in the light of their translations into english. Towards a model for the study of film adaptation as. Towards a model for the study of film adaptation as intersemiotic translation abstract the aim of this paper is to put forward a model which builds on the affinities between translation and adaptation and which can be used to systematise the analysis of film adaptation as a modality of translation. The aim of this issue will be to discuss theoretical and practical problems of intersemiotic translation and the debates surrounding it.
On translation discusses various aspects of translation and was published in cambridge, massachusetts. In the first part of the study the authors outline the analysed type of culturespecific words, summarise the generally acknowledged procedures of transferring culturally marked items. Shakespeare on screen rachel weissbrod department of translation and interpreting studies, bar ilan university abstract cinematic adaptations of shakespeares plays have been an important part of the history. Meanwhile, the necessity of teaching translation and. Not all translation studies scholars would agree that intersemiotic translation is actually translation. The effect of intersemiotic translation on vocabulary learning. The locus of the interpretant is not the translation target itself, but the creative process that in the future will result in the translation target. Furthermore, the need for translation within the same language is also indicative of the richness of perspectives, knowledge and cultures that exist within our linguistic. Introduction to intersemiotic translation translation is typically thought of as involving language, in particular written language. She has collaborated on various intersemiotic translation games projects with ricarda vidal, including still in translation and translation games in schools in 2015 and the current project childs play. Article pdf available october 2009 with 1,061 reads. In literary translation, a text is translated into another text using purely verbal means.
Does the quality of interlingual translation influence the quality of the intersemiotic translation. Pessimistic and optimistic views on translation are also represented by the. Does the quality of interlingual translation influence the. It is a major focus of literary and film studies which couples these two relevant disciplines. Translation studies, on the other hand, which had established itself much earlier than adaptation studies as a discipline, has by now expanded to include a wide array of subfields. Theories, problems, analysis article pdf available in semiotica 2015206 august 2015 with 8,638 reads how we measure reads. On linguistic aspects of translation is an essay written by russian linguist roman jakobson in 1959. Intersemiotic translation in everyday communication. Towards a model for the study of film adaptation as intersemiotic translation abstract the aim of this paper is to put forward a model which builds on the affinities between translation and adaptation and which can be used to systematise the analysis of film adaptation as a. Intersemiotic translation, cognitive artefact, and creativity. Introduction semiotics of translation, translation in semiotics. Pdf towards a model of intersemiotic translation researchgate.
We are an open access, academic journal which publishes on an annual basis. Romeo and juliet, he actually performed an intersemiotic translation. Semiosis and intersemiotic translation article pdf available in semiotica 20196. Oct 01, 2011 3 intersemiotic translation or transmutation is an interpretation of verbal signs by means of signs of nonverbal sign systems. Intersemiotic translations of rubaiyat of omar khayyam by iranian and thai illustrators. Intersemiotic translation it was defined by roman jakobson the translation studies reader, routledge, london, p. After a quiz, you will see a video about another type of interlingual translation. The first is translation within the same language, referred to as intralingual translation. The expression code was changed entirely from words to musical sounds. Thus globalization gives us the chance to promote new messages that contribute, in their turn, to a series of cultural interpretations that enrich the.
180 620 549 575 423 536 881 607 804 1477 1489 491 1089 1100 335 1332 1287 283 116 682 1393 487 800 1171 277 614 902 1526 832 1124 554 281 112 915 153 55 960 728 437 991 641 1116